Cat Birthday Cake

In this post, I’ll walk you through how to make a cat-friendly birthday cake using simple ingredients that are totally feline-approved.

If you’re in the mood for more sweet creations, check out our cozy Apple Spice Cake or the unique Gulab Jamun Cake Recipe for dessert inspiration. By the end, you’ll have the purr-fect little cake that’s sure to make your kitty’s big day extra special.

Why Make a Cat Birthday Cake?

Sure, your cat might not know it’s their birthday, but they’ll definitely appreciate the extra treats and attention. And let’s face it, we’re really doing this for us—to make memories and spoil our little fur babies. Here’s why it’s worth making a birthday cake for your cat:

• Special Bonding Moment: Baking something special just for them shows how much you care. It’s a small act that speaks volumes.
• Tailored to Their Taste: Unlike store-bought treats, you know exactly what’s going into this cake. No mystery ingredients, no weird additives—just wholesome goodness.
• Instagram-Worthy: Let’s be honest, who doesn’t want adorable photos of their cat digging into their birthday treat? It’s the kind of content that’ll make all your friends go “aww.”

So, grab your mixing bowl, and let’s get started! Your cat deserves to be celebrated in style.

Everything You’ll Need to Make It

This is everything you’ll need to make the filling, frosting, and then decorate the cat birthday cake with. If you know your kitty doesn’t like one of the following ingredients, feel free to swap it out. Note: exact measurements are in the recipe card below.

• Dry Cat Treats: Some of these will be blended into a powder and added to the cat food. Be sure to also save extra for decorating! I used Temptations cat treats but any type will work.
• Canned Pate Cat Food: I recommend staying away from shreds or anything too liquid-y so your cake can hold its shape.
• Plain Instant Mashed Potatoes: Plain is key here! You don’t want any extra seasonings or spices added, as they can upset your cat’s digestive system.
• Catnip: (For topping) Not only gives the cake a decorative touch, but makes it more irresistible to your cats.

All these ingredients are safe for cats and easy to find at your local grocery store or pet store. They’re basic, but trust me, they come together like magic for this adorable cake.

Step-by-Step Instructions to Create Your Cat Birthday Cake

1. Gather Your Supplies

Before diving in, make sure you’ve got everything ready. This isn’t a complicated recipe, but having the right tools on hand makes the process smooth and fun:

• Mixing bowl
• Spoon or spatula
• Measuring cup
• A small round dish or ramekin (to shape the cake)
• A knife or piping bag for decorating

Pro tip: If you don’t have a ramekin, you can shape the cake by hand. Cats aren’t picky about presentation—it’s all about the taste! Plus, a “rustic” look just adds to the homemade charm.

2. Prepare the Cake Base

Open the can of pate cat food and scoop it into your mixing bowl. Use your spoon to mix it up and get it nice and smooth. This will be the base of your cake, and it’s where all the meaty goodness comes from.

Next, add ⅓ cup of the prepared instant mashed potatoes. Stir everything together until it’s well combined. The potatoes act as a “binder” to hold the cake together and give it a fluffy texture that’s easy for your cat to eat.

3. Shape the Cake

Spoon the mixture into your ramekin or shape it into a small round cake on a plate. Press it down gently to make sure it holds its shape. If you’re feeling creative, you can even mold it into other shapes, like a heart or a fish. Just keep it simple enough for your cat to enjoy.

4. Decorate the Cake

This is the fun part! Take your dry cat treats and press them gently into the sides of the cake. You can get creative here—arrange them in a pattern, create a border, or scatter them randomly for a playful look. It’s like decorating a regular cake, but way cuter.

For the finishing touch, sprinkle a pinch of catnip on top. It’s like the cherry on a sundae, but for cats. If your cat isn’t a fan of catnip, you can skip this step and stick to the treats.

5. Serve and Celebrate

Carefully place the cake on a plate and present it to your cat. Don’t forget to take some photos or a video—this is a moment you’ll want to remember. Watch as your kitty digs in and enjoys their special treat! Seeing their little face light up (okay, maybe not literally) is the best reward.

Tips and Variations for Making the Perfect Cat Birthday Cake

This cat birthday cake recipe is very adaptable to your cat’s individual tastes!

• Switch Up the Pate: The canned cat food can be whatever cat food your kitty loves, as long as it’s a pate. Tuna, chicken, salmon, you name it! The other wet cat foods have too much liquid and will not form a cake as they are supposed to.
• Use Different Treats: As long as the cat treats can be blended into powder, use whichever brand you have on hand.
• Adjust Consistency: The instant potato “frosting” should be pretty thick. It’s best to mix water into it a little at a time until it’s a good consistency to spread. If it has too much water and is sloughing off the cake, you can add some more dry instant potatoes to thicken it back up.
• Different Frosting: Instead of mashed potatoes, you can also use pumpkin or sweet potato puree.
• Ramekin Alternatives: If you don’t have a ramekin, you can use a small bowl or Tupperware to shape the cake.
• Add Toppings: Decorate with your favorite cat treats! Garnish with a sardine or tiny canned shrimp. Press catnip all around the outside of the cake to act as sprinkles. Have fun making this the ultimate kitty cake!

Tips for Storing Your Cat’s Cake

If your cat doesn’t finish their cake in one sitting, here’s how to store it properly:

• Wrap leftovers in plastic wrap or place them in an airtight container.
• Store in the refrigerator and use within 1-2 days for maximum freshness.
• Bring it to room temperature before serving to make it more palatable for your cat.

Print

FAQs About Cat Birthday Cakes

Final Thoughts

Making a cat birthday cake might sound a little extra, but trust me—it’s so worth it. Your cat gets a tasty treat, you get adorable photos, and it’s a fun way to show your furry friend how much they mean to you. Plus, it’s a great excuse to celebrate all the joy they bring into your life.

So, the next time your cat’s special day rolls around, skip the store-bought treats and whip up this homemade cake instead. It’s quick, easy, and guaranteed to make your cat’s tail wag (well, metaphorically speaking—unless you have a dog, too). Honestly, it’s a win-win for everyone.

Now go celebrate that amazing kitty of yours! And hey, don’t forget to share your cake-making adventures in the comments below. I’d love to see how your version turned out. Let’s make every cat’s birthday as special as they are!